Blume, J. (1988). Are you there God? It’s me margaret. New York: Delacorte Press.
Margaret is just your average pre-teen trying to make it through life’s changes. Her parents have moved her out of New York City and into a town in New Jersey. Margaret finds a group of girls that call themselves the PTS’s (Pre-Teen Sensations) and they are all about boys, popularity and the changes of life. Margaret has to deal with her family’s issues, school, her friends, the changes of life as well as figure out who or what she wants to believe in. Throughout her struggles she always talks to God and waits for a reply; but those don’t always come as quickly or the way she wants them to. Will Margaret figure out all these problems before her world comes crashing down?
Are You There God? It’s Me Margaret is a coming of age realistic fiction novel that follows a pre-teen through a time of many changes. Margaret has moved to a different town, been taken away from the grandmother she loves, found new friends who gossip about everything, is trying to figure out who or what she wants to believe in and on top of all that her body is changing and fast! Many topics are brought up in this book. It fits many categories of realistic fiction. The rite-of- passage (emotional realism) comes when Margaret’s friends say you are not a real woman until you get your period. They all discuss how it might be when it happens and how proud they will be. There are also social ties (social realism) in the book that are explored when Margaret tries out various religions to see which one she feels she belongs to. Religion is a big struggle for her because her parents never told her what to believe and she doesn’t know what to believe and even doubts God when she feels like everything is going awry. This also goes along with Margaret’s moral choices. She has to decide if she is going to do what everyone else tells her to do, like mistreating a girl in class because Nancy, the leader of their group, does not like her.
As with any pre-teen realistic fiction novel, this book discusses many physical, emotional and behavioral changes in girls. It discusses boys, family dynamics, religion, peer influence and physical changes that occur during those years. So, this book would be most appropriate for girls around the ages of 11-13. This would be a good book for girls to read with their mothers, with a small group of friends, or even independently. One caution for teachers and parents is that they need to be ready to answer many questions that may arise from their pre-teen reading this book.
Some big questions that can be raised are:
1. How would you feel if your parents made you leave the town you grew up in?
2. Do you think Margaret’s parents should have kept her in a church or synagogue or let her choose her own beliefs? Why?
3. If a friend lied to you as much as Nancy lied to Margaret, would you still be their friend? Why or why not?
4. Why do you think Margaret stopped talking to God?
5. Who would you go to if you had a problem in your life?
A great strategy to use with a group of girls when reading this book and answering these questions would be a literature circle. This would be a safe place for girls to discuss the issues that come up in the book as well as learn from each other, a teacher or other adult.
This book has lasted since it was first published in 1970. Even though many have read it and loved it, it has been challenged to be taken off library shelves and out of the classroom. I can see where some parents would not like their daughter reading about female changes from a book, however, I do still think this is a book many pre-teen girls can relate to. Many of the situations in the book are very common for some girls. If this book allows them to escape and feel as if they are not alone in their struggles and it could raise some questions that the young girls need answered, then I don’t see a problem with it. This is why I would recommend it to any teacher or librarian. These girls need books like these to help them sort out life’s problems, and Judy Blume does that in a very nice way.

I remember reading this book myself when fairly young. Do you think it is written so that girls of today can relate and not think it is old-fashioned?
ReplyDelete